283323 9

‘Tethered’ Review: ‘Black & White’ Lite

by Jamie Feltham • October 28th, 2016
Positives

+ A meaty game that will appeal to hardcore gamers
+ Unlike anything else in VR right now
+ Beautiful worlds to immerse yourself in

Negatives

- No free camera movement
- Too much micromanagement
- Head-tracked controls lack finesse

How did it take someone this long to make a VR god game? Headsets have only been out a few months, but the thought of taking one of gaming’s most beloved genres and actually making you that omnipotent being is so compelling I’m surprised that Secret Sorcery wasn’t beaten to it. Even more intriguing is that it’s been done first on PlayStation 4 with PlayStation VR, and not the genre’s usual home on PC.

As a first stab at this type of game, Tethered is pretty successful. It translates some staple features like resource gathering, elemental management and prayer systems with great results, but it’s not without its stumbles.

In Tethered, you are a Spirit Guardian, and your subjects are Peeps, adorable little critters, hatched from eggs that drift down from the heavens above. In each of the 13 levels, you’ll need to raise your Spirit Energy to a certain amount by scooping it up as your minions/subjects/believers farm resources, defeat enemies and make prayers. As Peeps work for you, you’ll need to keep them happy by making sure food is well stocked, health is full, and everyone is busy. Ignore the prayers of a Peep for too long and they’ll jump off a cliff. Really, they’ll become depressed and sleep walk over to the nearest rock and step off.

It’s a dark turn for what’s otherwise a bright and breezy game. Staring down into Tethered‘s floating worlds from above is a sheer delight in VR. Leaning in to inspect tiny details like the stalks of wheat that grow in farms or surround yourself in butterflies as they hover below is absolutely lovely. You move around the island by teleporting between a handful of set positions, represented as clouds.

That’s where the game’s first issue rises from. Tethered‘s locomotion is restricted and often frustrating, especially during the nighttime sections of levels in which beasts attack and you’ll quickly have to order Peeps to fight them. This is done by looking at your unit, pressing and holding the X button, and then ‘tethering’ them to the enemy by looking at them and letting go. That’s how you perform all of the game’s actions.

At times, you’ll want a specific Peep for a specific job, but from where you’re looking you won’t be able to select them both. Moving the camera to see them should be as simple as using the analogue sticks to fly through the air, but Tethered doesn’t support this kind of movement. Instead, you have to find a cloud that will give you a better angle, which involves looking away from the targets and gathering your bearings once more.

It’s more than likely the most comfortable option, but the game doesn’t even use the sticks, which is infuriating for people that don’t suffer from sim sickness. Games like Kittypocalypse prove that you can have comfortable free-flying camera movement.

It means that flatter levels in Tethered, where you can see most of the world around you, are decidedly better than the multi-layered areas that are intentionally designed to keep you moving about. The game zig-zags in enjoyment from level-to-level, though the learning curve can also make some of the earlier levels a challenge. Learning and perfecting all of the games’ systems stretches well beyond the already-lengthy tutorial, and you’ll undoubtedly be able to improve scores in previous levels as you get better toward the end of the game.

That’s testament to some pretty excellent design. When you finally master all of Tethered‘s mechanics, including making sure all your Peeps are doing something at all times and regularly using elements to replenish supplies and open up new areas, the game has a great flow to it. It’s a demanding process, especially if you’re going for A ranks across Peep happiness, use of elements and timing, but learning how to juggle it all is a big part of the fun.

Less key to that system are the upgrades. In each level you’ll unlock a set of buildings that can speed up workers, offer more Spirit Energy, create more efficient resource gatherers and more. Each of these buildings can be upgraded, but I never needed more than two or three of them across the entire campaign, and some of their specific functions unnecessarily complicate matters. Upgrading your Peeps is also inessential unless you’re aiming for the best scores. Ultimately, it was a side of the game I largely forgot about as I played.

30315819365_07157db6e2_h

Still, the amount of micromanaging required here can occasionally become overwhelming, and not in a good way. During the day cycles in Tethered, it’s quite easy to keep Peeps working. During night, however, things become a bit more confusing. As slug-like enemies attack, you’ll need to assign Peeps to go and fight them, and they’ll also fight any they naturally come across. The system doesn’t always work flawlessly; you can send three warriors off to fight a pack of monsters and then look back a few seconds later to find only one of them actually fighting while the others stand by the first one they’ve killed.

Also working against these moments are the head-tracked controls, which lack the finesse required in tight situations. I’d often trying to get one Peep to help another in a fight but accidentally target a small stack of resources sitting next to the battle, and then watch them pick up those resources and leave with their friend in need.

That puts the Peep still fighting at risk of dying needlessly, and in the heat of battle you might neglect some that have already defeated their monsters and are now on the other side of the map. If you leave them for too long they’re going to get depressed, which feels like a needless mechanic. It seems strange to find a Peep kicking around with nothing to do when he could be mining the pile of rocks right next to him. By making you assign every single action and punishing you for not noticing something, Tethered can suddenly leave you with a mess on your hands when you thought everything was okay.

But, in a way, I appreciate that Tethered has these issues, because it demonstrates what Secret Sorcery is really trying to achieve here: a meaty, full videogame. At about seven hours (each level takes between 25 – 45 minutes) it’s lengthier than most VR games, and its mechanics are deeper, no matter how flawed.

30280768246_e191aed620_h

Final Score: 7/10 – Good

Though far from the likes of XCOM, Tethered is a more demanding strategy game than anything we’ve yet seen in VR. Though its islands are smaller and its matches are shorter than something like Black & White, it’s the first VR game to even resemble that type of experience. Tethered is far from perfect, but it also represents something that a lot of hardcore gamers will be pining for after 45 minute Batman experiences; something they can really sink their teeth into. For hardcore VR videogames it is, quite simply, a good start.

Curious about this score? Check out our review guidelines for more information.

Tagged with: , , , ,

What's your reaction?
Like
Wow
0%
LOL
0%
Dislike
0%
  • unreal_ed

    -1 for not naming the review “Black & Lite”

    • Wildattorney

      Microsoft would have something to say about that if they did. The same way you won’t see a third person shooter for PSVR called Gears of VR.

      • unreal_ed

        I said naming the REVIEW (aka the article) “Black & Lite”, not the game

        • M0rdresh

          And even then; I don’t think Microsoft has a trademark on the name Black &Lite

          • unreal_ed

            Yea but if a game were to be called that they could maybe have a claim. The idea is generally about whether or not the infringer’s trademark could be mistaken for the infringed. So if the logo and the game were completely different then you would probably be fine

  • unreal_ed

    I do really hope that this genre picks up in VR. Ideally they would go even MORE Black and White and have the virtual pet that those games had, because they would be awesome to pet/slap/play with with motion controls or hand-tracking

  • M0rdresh

    Will this come to PC eventually?

    • Sebastien Mathieu

      I hope that they are all just “timed exclusive“

  • Nate

    I just played Tethered last night for 2 1/2 hours straight and didn’t even realize I was playing that long without a break. That’s a testament for how well designed the game is and how fun it was for me. Although I was playing for that long I sadly only got through the tutorial and mostly through the first level but I’m apparently pretty awful player right now but I know I’ll get better in time once I get a hang of keeping all of the Peeps busy and happy and replenishing the resources with the weather systems. Like Jamie says in the article the micromanagement can be a bit overwhelming (at least for me) and I had about 5 Peeps off themselves within a 5 minute period which set me back considerably. So far this is the most fun I’ve had playing the PS VR and also the longest I’ve gone without taking a break or feeling like I needed to. I agree with just about 99% of the author’s critiques regarding this game and I hope they patch some of the shortcomings which make the game a little too unforgiving at times, much like they just did with Battlezone (easing up a tad on the unforgiving difficulty to make it a bit more fun). If you’re looking for a longer and more in depth VR experience this is the game to get. Plus it’s on sale for a couple bucks off for PS Plus members. Get it, you’ll love it if you enjoy strategy games.